The Superhuman ClubBy Muscleheadon

Journal · Supplements

The supplement shelf, sorted into four

First published 8 January 2020 · revised November 2026

A supplement shelf looks as though it needs a qualification to read. It does not. Take away the lightning bolts and the lettering and most of what is up there falls into a handful of categories, each one a familiar part of food in a concentrated, convenient form. Four of them are among the most common.

Protein powder

Protein that has been separated from a food and dried. The food might be milk, which gives whey and casein, or egg, soy, pea, rice or a mixture. Whey is the most common. It is filtered from the liquid left over in cheese-making and sold in three forms, which are untangled in concentrate, isolate and hydrolysate.

You mix it with water or milk as a convenient way to add protein to the day. It is a food ingredient. It does nothing that the same amount of protein from a meal would not do, which is worth remembering when the tub implies otherwise.

Mass gainer

Looks like protein powder, is mostly carbohydrate. The bulk is commonly maltodextrin or powdered oats, with protein and a smaller amount of fat alongside, which makes it calorie-dense. The whole difference between the two tubs is one of proportion. Mass gainers explained has the detail.

BCAAs

This one needs a little background. Protein is built from amino acids, and nine of them are essential, meaning your body cannot make them and they must come from food. Three of the nine, leucine, isoleucine and valine, have a branched chemical structure. They are sold together as BCAAs, usually as a flavoured powder to sip during training.

All three are already present in any complete protein, including whey, eggs, dairy and meat. Whether a separate BCAA product adds anything for someone who already eats enough protein is a question on which the evidence is mixed. See BCAAs explained.

Protein bars

Protein powder in solid form, bound with syrups, nut butters or fibre, then usually coated or flavoured. Bars vary more widely than you might expect. Some are close to a confectionery bar with added protein. Others are mostly protein and fibre. The front of the wrapper will not tell you which kind you are holding, but the ingredient list and the nutrition panel will.

Side by side

  • Protein powder: mostly protein, mixed as a drink.
  • Mass gainer: mostly carbohydrate with protein, used to add calories.
  • BCAAs: three specific amino acids, without the rest of the protein.
  • Protein bar: protein you can carry, plus whatever is needed to hold it together.

None of these is where you start. Food comes first, and a supplement fills a known gap. If you take one skill away from this shelf, make it reading the label, which is more use than knowing the names on the front of the tub.

At The Superhuman Club, supplement stacks are built from blood markers by a nutritionist.

First published on the earlier Muscleheadon site and rewritten for The Superhuman Club in November 2026. It is general information, not medical advice.

All articles