The Superhuman ClubBy Muscleheadon

Journal · Supplements

Mass gainers: a meal in a tub

First published 10 January 2020 · revised November 2026

The first clue is the scoop. Open a mass gainer and the scoop inside is far bigger than the one in a protein tub. That tells you most of what you need to know. This is food in powder form, and a lot of it.

People confuse it with protein powder because the two sit side by side on the shelf in near-identical tubs. They are built differently. A protein powder is mostly protein, with little carbohydrate or fat. A gainer is mostly carbohydrate, with protein second and a smaller amount of fat, so a serving is much larger and carries far more calories.

What it is made from

The carbohydrate is usually maltodextrin, a powder derived from starch that dissolves easily. Some products use powdered oats, rice or other grain flours, and some add sugars. The protein is most often whey, sometimes blended with casein, egg or plant proteins. The fat commonly comes from vegetable oil powders or medium-chain triglycerides.

Many tubs then add vitamins, minerals, creatine or digestive enzymes. These extras change from one product to the next, so the ingredient list is the only reliable guide to what you are holding.

If that recipe sounds familiar, it should. You can make a similar drink in your own mixer with milk, oats, a banana, a spoon of nut butter and a scoop of protein powder. A gainer is that drink with the shopping and the washing-up removed.

Who it suits

Gainers are for people whose training programme calls for more food than they comfortably eat. Drinking calories is easier than chewing them, and a shake takes little time to make. The usual users have small appetites, long working days or heavy training loads.

It is normally mixed with water or milk. Because a full serving is large, some people split it across the day instead of facing it in one go.

Before you pick one up

Turn the tub round and check four things.

  • The ratio of carbohydrate to protein, which varies considerably between products.
  • Where the carbohydrate comes from, and how much of it is sugar.
  • The serving size, because every figure on the nutrition panel is based on it.
  • Any added ingredients, and whether their amounts are stated.

Reading a protein label goes through this in more detail.

The plain view is that a mass gainer is a convenience food. Its calories come from the same carbohydrate, protein and fat as your ordinary meals, and it is useful only when eating enough is the practical difficulty. If you can meet your needs from the plate, it adds calories and little else. For the rest of the shelf, see supplement types explained.

First published on the earlier Muscleheadon site and rewritten for The Superhuman Club in November 2026. It is general information, not medical advice.

All articles